Rings That
Begin Forever
Our collection is hand-selected and ever-changing. Call or visit to see what’s currently in store.
FILTERS
Diamond Education
Understanding the Four C's
The universal language for evaluating diamond quality. A little knowledge goes a long way — let’s talk you through it. Want the full story? Read our North Shore buyer’s guide to the 4 C’s and our honest take on lab-grown vs. natural diamonds.
Cut
The most important factor. A well-cut diamond reflects light brilliantly regardless of color or clarity. We source only excellent and ideal cuts.
Color
Graded D (colorless) to Z (light yellow). For most settings, a G–H color is near-colorless and indistinguishable to the naked eye — ideal value.
Clarity
Natural diamonds have inclusions. VS2–SI1 stones are eye-clean and a smart choice — the difference from FL is invisible without magnification.
Carat
Weight, not size. A well-cut 0.95ct looks larger than a poorly-cut 1.0ct. We'll help you balance carat with the other Cs for the best result.
What Our Couples Have To Say
Ira helped me design a custom ring that was absolutely perfect. He understood exactly what I was looking for — she said yes before I even finished the question.
We spent an afternoon at Cottage Jewelry and never once felt rushed. They educated us, showed us options in our range, and the ring was ready ahead of schedule. Exceptional.
The staff are wonderful and the ring selection is gorgeous. We have been coming here for years and wouldn't go anywhere else. You can't find a more honest jeweler than Ira.
Find Your Perfect Ring
Visit our Evanston showroom to see our full collection in person. No appointment needed — walk in anytime and let us help you find the one.
