Evanston Jeweler Since 1973
Custom Engagement Rings, Fine Jewelry, & a Fair Offer on Your Gold
Design a ring from scratch or give an heirloom a new life, on Dempster Street since 1973.
Selling? Every piece is tested in front of you and paid by check the same visit.
If You're Not
Wearing It, Sell It.
Since 1973
A Legacy of Fine Jewelry in the
Heart of Evanston
For over five decades, Cottage Jewelry has been the trusted destination for engagement rings, custom designs, and expertly curated fine jewelry. We take pride in being a fair and private place to sell the gold and estate jewelry you no longer wear, just off Dempster Street and minutes from Wilmette, Skokie and Winnetka.
Our Collections
Explore Our Curated Pieces
Our Craftsmanship
Where Artistry Meets Precision
Every ring, necklace, and bracelet that leaves our workshop carries the hallmark of meticulous hand-finishing and decades of accumulated expertise. Our master jewelers combine time-honored techniques with modern precision tools.
From selecting ethically sourced gemstones to the final polish, we oversee every detail — ensuring your piece is not just beautiful, but built to last for generations.
50+
Years of Expertise
10k+
Custom Pieces
100%
Handcrafted
What Our Clients Say
It is an absolutely wonderful experience every time visiting Cottage Jewelry. You can literally talk to anyone in the store and they will try whatever they can to help you.
The staff here are so warm and welcoming and knowledgeable, I have felt like an absolute princess every time I walk through the door. I have timeless pieces from this store.
Ira and his team are the best. They go out of their way and are friends, not just a business. The selection is very good, prices reasonable, and the unique settings are a bonus.
You can't find a more honest jeweler than Ira! The prices are affordable and the quality is amazing. We've been coming here for years and wouldn't go anywhere else.
Our Services
Beyond the Showcase
Repair & Restore
Expert repairs, stone replacement, and restoration to bring beloved heirlooms back to their original glory.
Custom Jewelry Design
Collaborate with our master jewelers to create a one-of-a-kind piece that captures your unique story.
Appraisals
GIA-certified appraisals for insurance, estate planning, or your own peace of mind.
We Buy Gold
Fair, transparent offers for your gold, silver, platinum, and estate jewelry. Walk-ins welcome.
Begin Your Journey
Visit our Evanston studio and experience the personal attention that has made us this community’s jeweler for over fifty years.
